Top Cape May Restaurants for a Perfect Date Night | Romantic Dining Guide
The deSatnick Real Estate TeamAugust 28 2024

Decorative image
galleries/blog/08282024162851_download.jpg galleries/blog/08282024162852_primal-by-mia-cape-may-nj-interior-5-768x512.jpg galleries/blog/08282024162852_348s.jpg
Discover the best restaurants in Cape May for a romantic date night. From elegant fine dining to cozy, intimate settings, explore top spots like The Ebbitt Room, Peter Shields Inn, Tisha’s, and more for a memorable evening.

Planning a romantic evening out in Cape May? This charming seaside town offers an array of dining options perfect for a memorable date night. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply enjoying a night out, these top restaurants in Cape May set the stage for an unforgettable experience.

Pre-Meal Activities:

1. Take a Walk

Depending on the location of the restaurant, parking may be difficult. If you enjoy going for a relaxing stroll, take advantage of free parking and walk along the beachfront or through the historic streets to start your night.

  • Local Tip: The East side of town has a lot of meter free parking, specifically as you move farther from the beach.

2. The Washington Street Mall

Stroll along the Washington Street mall and enjoy over 75 establishments that offer a variety of shops, bars, restaurants, and ice cream parlors.There are plenty of seating areas to relax and “people watch”.

  • Local Tip: The Cape May MAC (Museums, Arts, Culture) has an information booth at the corner of Washington and Ocean Streets where you can buy tickets for the trolley, walking tours, Cape May Point Lighthouse, and more.

3. Stop at a Cocktail Bar

Explore Cape May’s cocktail scene by visiting bars like The Brown room, a stylish lounge occupying the same spot as Congress Hall’s first legal post-Prohibition cocktail bar, and The Mad Batter, renowned for its creative concoctions and lively atmosphere. For a more intimate setting, try The Cricket Club, offering unique twists on classic cocktails. 

  • Local Tip: Cape May Free Ride is a “Hop On” or “ On Call” free service where a golf cart will pick you up and drop you off around the island. * Drivers are unpaid so tips are appreciated*

Restaurant Recommendations:

1. The Ebbitt Room

Located in the heart of Cape May, The Ebbitt Room offers an elegant and intimate dining experience. Known for its farm-to-table cuisine, this restaurant emphasizes fresh, locally sourced ingredients. The sophisticated atmosphere, complete with candlelit tables and soft music, creates the perfect setting for romance.

2. Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant

For those looking to indulge in a fine dining experience, Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant is a top choice. Situated in a grand, historic mansion with ocean views, this restaurant is renowned for its gourmet dishes and impeccable service. The romantic ambiance is enhanced by the stunning surroundings, making it an ideal spot for a special night out.

3. Tisha’s Fine Dining

Tisha’s Fine Dining, located in the Washington Street Mall, offers a cozy yet refined atmosphere perfect for a casual yet romantic evening. With a menu that blends classic American dishes with a touch of Mediterranean flair, Tisha’s provides a unique dining experience in the heart of Cape May.

4. The Washington Inn

A Cape May staple, The Washington Inn combines historic charm with contemporary cuisine. Set in a beautifully restored 1840s home, this restaurant is known for its exceptional service and an extensive wine list. The dimly lit dining rooms and classic décor make it a go-to spot for couples looking to enjoy a sophisticated, romantic meal.

5. Primal by Mia

Nestled along the beachfront, Primal is an upscale open-fire steakhouse that pairs contemporary, casual vibes with refined dining. Alongside prime cuts, the menu features the freshest local seafood, with slight daily variations that keep things exciting. More than just a restaurant, Primal fosters a culture of mindful eating and drinking in a social setting. Reservations are required one week in advance for this exclusive dining experience.

Cape May’s vibrant dining scene offers a variety of options for creating the perfect date night. Whether you prefer an elegant fine dining experience or a cozy, intimate meal, these top restaurants provide the ideal setting for a romantic evening out.

Ready to make Cape May, the Wildwoods, or Lower Township your home. Contact DeSatnick Real Estate today to explore our listings and find your dream coastal property. Whether you're looking for a vacation home or a permanent residence, our team of expert agents is here to help you navigate the Jersey Shore real estate market.

DeSatnick Real Estate | From Shoreline to Skyline, Your Trusted Real Estate Advisors

With three convenient offices in Cape May, Lower Township, and North Wildwood, DeSatnick Real Estate is your go-to resource for all your Jersey Shore real estate needs. Our team of over 100 experienced agents specializes in both sales and rentals, offering unparalleled expertise and local knowledge to help you find your perfect coastal property. Whether you’re buying, selling, or renting, we are committed to delivering exceptional service and results across the Jersey Shore.

Contact Us Today to start your real estate journey with DeSatnick Real Estate, where local expertise meets exceptional service.

  • Cape May Office: 609.884.1300 | 1001 Lafayette Street, Cape May
  • Lower Township Office: 609.886.6000 | 2505 Bayshore Road, Unit 1, Villas
  • North Wildwood Office: 609.551.4066 | 901 New Jersey Avenue, North Wildwood